So the general story is that a long time ago, I guess around the turn of century, children began reporting that they were waking up to find candy left on their bedroom window sills. I don’t know why (maybe because candy was such a rare treat at the time?) but they didn’t tell their parents.
Then they started to find writing on the wrappers claiming that the candy was from the “Candy Lady” or “Candy Fairy”. Then a couple of kids, brother and sister, went missing. They were out on their property far from the house and just never came back.
Well, over the next couple of years or so, a few more kids went missing. That’s when some kids started to confess about eating strange candy left on their window sills from a Candy Lady. The kids were scared so they told their parents. Then a farmer found the rotten teeth of a child in a candy wrapper on the edge of one of his fields.
A police deputy started investigating then went missing. A few weeks later, they found his body in a shallow ditch. And here’s the creepy part- his eyes were stabbed. With a fork. He had candy in his pockets.
People said it was the Candy Lady. Any time any kid would go missing, all the local children would talk about how the Candy Lady got them. How she took them somewhere and pulled out their teeth or stabbed their eyes out with a fork.
Legend of the Candy Lady 